User Tools

Site Tools


taiji:wu_tu-nan
Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
taiji:wu_tu-nan [2017/06/23 12:25]
serena
taiji:wu_tu-nan [2017/06/23 12:25] (current)
serena
Line 3: Line 3:
 == Controversy == Controversy
 === Regarding Song Shu-Ming === Regarding Song Shu-Ming
-Song Shuming ​was a very creative man, who invented a fabulous taiji lineage and practiced a variant of the Yang Chengfu style mixed with Wu Jianquan style elements, as can be seen in his own book. Wu Tunan and Xu Yusheng apparently liked the made up story and wanted to ride Song's coattails and be part of his "​ancient"​ transmisson. Unfortunately Wu Tunan decided to smear his late teacher, Wu Jianquan'​s good name, by making him part of their story. Wu Jianquan learned from his father only and exchanged knowledge with his collegues Sun Lutang, Yang Chenfu, Yang Shaohou and others. Song Shuming'​s and Wu tunan'​s motives are very transparent and their story about a more than thousand year old daoist taiji lineage, that incidentally looks like a Yang Chengfu/Wu Jianquan hybrid form is pretty laughable.+[[Song Shu-ming]] ​was a very creative man, who invented a fabulous taiji lineage and practiced a variant of the Yang Chengfu style mixed with Wu Jianquan style elements, as can be seen in his own book. Wu Tunan and Xu Yusheng apparently liked the made up story and wanted to ride Song's coattails and be part of his "​ancient"​ transmisson. Unfortunately Wu Tunan decided to smear his late teacher, Wu Jianquan'​s good name, by making him part of their story. Wu Jianquan learned from his father only and exchanged knowledge with his collegues Sun Lutang, Yang Chenfu, Yang Shaohou and others. Song Shuming'​s and Wu tunan'​s motives are very transparent and their story about a more than thousand year old daoist taiji lineage, that incidentally looks like a Yang Chengfu/Wu Jianquan hybrid form is pretty laughable.
  
 The fabricated story by Wu Tunan is much later than 1911. Xu Yusheng'​s book from 1921 doesn'​t really say that much about Song Shuming. Xu basically says that he practiced with Song and benefited from it. He doesn'​t give any personal information about his age or occupation. He also just says about Song: 善太極拳術 - He is good in the art of Taijiquan. He doesn'​t say where he learned it. He also says that he contributed 發明 - His own inventions! Wu Tunan apparently liked the alleged [[Song Yuan-qiao]] lineage story and built his story around it. The fabricated story by Wu Tunan is much later than 1911. Xu Yusheng'​s book from 1921 doesn'​t really say that much about Song Shuming. Xu basically says that he practiced with Song and benefited from it. He doesn'​t give any personal information about his age or occupation. He also just says about Song: 善太極拳術 - He is good in the art of Taijiquan. He doesn'​t say where he learned it. He also says that he contributed 發明 - His own inventions! Wu Tunan apparently liked the alleged [[Song Yuan-qiao]] lineage story and built his story around it.
taiji/wu_tu-nan.txt · Last modified: 2017/06/23 12:25 by serena